UFO and UAP Disinformation: The Invisible War For Perception
- JR Prudence: Jedaiah Ramnarine
- 5 days ago
- 11 min read
UFO DISINFORMATION: THE INVISIBLE WAR FOR PERCEPTION
Astroturfing, Bots, Narrative Control & the Multi-Layered Disinformation Apparatus in the Modern UFO/NHI Landscape creates UFO disinformation
By Jedaiah Ramnarine (JR Prudence)
Astroturfing has become the dominant force in online UFO/NHI discussions, particularly on Reddit. Rather than genuine public skepticism, experiencers now face coordinated botnets, pre-scripted debunking clusters, synchronized downvotes, and narrative-shaping operations that flood threads with dismissive comments designed to create the illusion of “majority opinion.” These systems are not attempting to understand or debate. Their purpose is to overwhelm perception, enforce mundane explanations, and psychologically condition witnesses to doubt their own experiences.
Through firsthand experiments posting real footage—including a 40,000-foot orb squadron, a daylight metallic disc, and a boomerang craft—JRP observed identical behavior patterns: instant debunking scripts, repetitive comments across unrelated threads, large clusters of instant upvotes, and a refusal to engage with evidence. When suppression fails, distraction botnets activate, using meme posts and emotional bait to drown meaningful content.
Manufactured hoaxes also play a role, rising rapidly before collapsing publicly to demoralize audiences and erode trust. The resulting landscape leaves experiencers isolated, self-censoring, and pressured to conform to synthetic consensus.
This post exposes how digital perception warfare is shaping the UFO/NHI narrative and why independent platforms like JRP are essential for real disclosure. The problem is not lack of evidence — it is deliberate manipulation of public belief through coordinated astroturfing.
Introduction: What I Learned From “Testing the Waters”
Over the past few weeks, I performed an elementary experiment.
I took some of my footage—not even all of it, not even the strongest material, and not even linking back to the J.R. Prudence platform—and I quietly posted it on Reddit to see what would happen. These posts hit #1 in multiple subreddits with hundreds of thousands of organic views, hitting over a million with the combined efforts from a month ago.
What unfolded was not surprising, but it was illuminating in its scale, its coordination, and the strange consistency of the behaviors involved.
Some people were kind, supportive, or genuinely curious.
Some were jealous, aggressive, or transparently insecure.
But then there was a third category, and this is where things get interesting:
Accounts that were neither human-acting nor reality-based.
Accounts that:
latched onto narratives that made no sense
repeated debunking lines, even when the evidence contradicted them
insisted on incorrect interpretations even when provided context
behaved in patterns identical to coordinated astroturfing operations
downvoted in clusters
showed synchronized posting behavior
pushed the same talking points across unrelated threads
appeared moments after a post went live
and rewrote the entire comment atmosphere through volume, not argument
This wasn’t normal skepticism.
This wasn’t people disagreeing.
This was a manufactured consensus.
And once you’ve recognized the fingerprints of coordinated narrative control, you cannot unsee them.
This chapter is my comprehensive analytical dive into that system—what it is, how it operates, and how I witnessed it firsthand across multiple threads. It explores why the UFO/NHI topic serves as a magnet for this behavior and why it matters now more than ever.
This is not a conspiracy—this is simply how modern media, propaganda, and digital ecosystems actually function in 2025.
1. What Astroturfing Really Is—and Why People Underestimate It
Most people think astroturfing means “fake grassroots support.”
That is one tiny fraction of what it actually is.
Modern astroturfing involves:
1.1. Synthetic Narrative Shaping to create UFO disinformation, distraction, and misdirection
Creating the illusion that “the majority” believes something (or disbelieves something) through sheer volume. This includes:
bots
sock-puppets
burner accounts
paid shills
coordinated brigades
automated comment clusters
psychological steering agents
1.2. Algorithmic Weighting
Platforms reward posts that receive early engagement.
Astroturfing exploits this by:
deploying immediate, synchronized comments
upvoting specific narratives
downvoting counter-narratives
suppressing organic discussion
This creates an illusion of consensus, which most casual users instinctively obey.
1.3. Perception Herding
People assume what they see is what “everyone else” thinks.
Reddit in particular is notorious for this—the top comment becomes the truth, even if it is utterly wrong.
Astroturfing exploits this herd psychology.
1.4. The Goal Is Not Accuracy—The Goal Is Control
Astroturfing is not designed to be correct.
It is designed to dominate perception.
Whether the narrative is:
“It’s a meteor.”
“It’s a plane.”
“It’s a lake reflection.”
“It’s birds.”
“It’s satellites.”
“It’s camera shake.”
"It's skydivers."
"It's buildings."
“It’s nothing, stop being crazy.”
…it does not matter.
What matters is flooding the thread with anything other than the truth.
If the truth is inconvenient, simply bury it under noise.
That is the philosophy.
2. Why the UFO/NHI Topic Is Ground Zero for Astroturfing
The UFO subject is the perfect storm for narrative control:
2.1. It is emotionally charged
People care.
People get invested.
People defend their identity around their interpretation of reality.
High emotion = high manipulation value.
2.2. Governments have a long history of direct involvement
If there is any subject in the modern era with confirmed propaganda operations, psyops, infiltration, counterintelligence, and narrative management, it is UFOs.
This is not speculation.
This is historically documented.
2.3. It threatens multiple industries
Disclosure—real disclosure—would disrupt:
defense contracting
aerospace secrecy
religious institutions
political power structures
academia
certain scientific reputations
long-standing narratives of world order
2.4. It attracts hoaxers
Hoaxes make the topic easier to ridicule.
The “James Cylinder” phenomenon is a perfect example—an obvious hoax intentionally pushed into the spotlight, knowing it would later collapse and demoralize people.
These artificial rises and collapses generate trauma in audiences.
2.5. And because of all this… the topic must be managed.
It doesn’t matter who is managing it—governments, corporations, intelligence agencies, foreign actors, platform moderators, opportunists, or simply bots running automated scripts.
The point is: it is managed.
Aggressively. Systematically. Persistently.
3. My Reddit Case Study: Real Footage Meets Synthetic Consensus
Let’s go through what happened when I posted my material.
This is not theory—this is firsthand empirical data.
3.1. The Orb Squadron at 40,000 Feet
This was one of the clearest, most structured, most unambiguous captures I’ve ever shared.
What happened?
Within minutes:
Bot-like accounts appeared with identical phrasing across threads.
Assertions with zero engagement with the evidence:
“Lakes reflecting the sun” (at 40k feet over the North Atlantic)
“Lmao it’s reflections”
“Pilot here, those are lakes”
Comment clusters receiving instant upvotes (20–200+) regardless of accuracy.
Replies from me met with sudden synchronized downvotes.
Counter-explanations ignored entirely — not addressed, not debated.
Users demanding flight details, even though they would not accept them anyway.
Attempts to derail the topic by redirecting into arrogant banter, mockery, and dismissal.
People contradicting themselves within the same conversation — a hallmark of bot-assisted astroturfing.
This is the formula:
Deny → Mock → Redirect → Overwhelm → Control Perception
3.2. The Daylight Metallic Disk
Again, same pattern.
The footage was clear.
Well-framed.
Daylight.
Metallic object.
No wings.
No flapping.
No blur consistent with a bird.
What did the astroturf cluster do?
“It’s a plane."
“Birds can shine like that.”
“Your camera moved.”
(Despite the object holding steady, while static objects in frame remained stable.)
Comments upvoted instantly.
Any correction downvoted instantly.
And again, the exact same handful of accounts repeating the exact same lines across multiple threads.
3.3. The Boomerang UAP
Same phenomenon:
“Flock of birds.”
“Seagulls.”
“This is embarrassing.”
Dozens of upvotes within seconds.
The top comment becomes “truth,” enforced by synthetic agreement.
Even when I wrote a full testing methodology—months of comparisons, ecology checks, lens controls—it did not matter. Bots do not respond to context. They respond to mission parameters.
4. The Bot / Brigade / Sock-Puppet Indicators
Here’s what became obvious after watching multiple threads:
4.1. The Same Accounts Repeating Identical Phrases
Some users wrote the exact same “debunking line” verbatim across:
r/UFOs
r/Aliens
r/UFObelievers
r/InterdimensionalNHI
That’s not normal human behavior.
4.2. Instant Engagement
Comments appear within seconds, upvoted in clusters of 20–80 in minutes, regardless of content quality.
This is classic coordinated upvote manipulation.
4.3. The “Narrative Gravity” Effect
Once the synthetic consensus takes root, actual human users follow the lead because humans instinctively obey perceived social majority.
This is how astroturfing weaponizes human psychology.
4.4. Mockery as a Tool
Bots frequently employ:
sarcasm
one-liners
dismissals
rudeness
…because mockery is one of the fastest ways to shut down real discussion.
4.5. Reality-Blindness
No matter the footage, they repeat:
“It’s a plane.”
“It’s a meteor.”
“It’s reflections.”
“It’s birds.”
"It's a balloon." "It's AI." "It's CGI." "It's blurry."
The content of the video literally does not matter.
They would label a flying saucer at 10 meters the same way.
5. The Other Side of Astroturfing: Distraction Bots
Not all bots are hostile.
Not all bots are meant to debunk.
Some are meant to distract, derail, or flood.
Its posts receive:
instant traction
unusually high engagement
hyper-rapid climbing to the top
But the posts themselves are:
vague
emotionally charged
existential
ambiguous
This is not accidental.
Distraction is a form of control.
If you can’t suppress a topic, you flood it with noise until the signal disappears.
This is precisely what Ryan Holiday described in “Trust Me, I’m Lying”—the idea that digital spaces can be manipulated not just by argument, but by flooding, confusion, and psychological saturation.
6. Why “Debunking Scripts” Exist
There are only so many explanations the system wants people to believe.
That is why debunking operates like a script:
“Birds.”
“Plane.”
“Meteor.”
“Lens flare.”
“Reflection.”
“Skydivers.”
“Drone.”
“Bug near the lens.”
These are not real analyses.
They are automatic narrative placeholders.
Even when the explanation contradicts:
altitude
physics
weather
environment
camera settings
eyewitness context
aviation logs
meteor logs
satellite tracking
…the script continues.
This is because the purpose is not truth.
The purpose is closure.
If the audience feels like there is an explanation—even if it doesn’t fit—the cycle ends.
And the status quo remains safe.
7. The Psychological Warfare Element
Astroturfing does not just influence crowds.
It affects you, the experiencer.
It creates:
subconscious self-doubt
second-guessing
fear of ridicule
hesitation to share real evidence
internal conflict
self-censorship
And this is intentional.
If they can get you to silence yourself, they don’t have to do the work anymore.
This psychological manipulation is one of the most damaging aspects of narrative warfare.
8. Manufactured Hoaxes: Another Layer of Control
When the system wants to discredit the UFO topic, there is a playbook:
Push a hoax to the top of the algorithm.
Let thousands become invested.
Let the media amplify it.
Wait until belief reaches its peak.
Reveal that it was fake.
Watch the disillusionment and demoralization.
People withdraw from the subject entirely.
The James Cylinder situation is a textbook example.
Hoaxes are not just accidents—they are tools.
Tools used to make the public feel:
embarrassed
foolish
ashamed
distrustful
apathetic
The longer people stay demoralized, the less likely they are to accept real evidence.
9. Why Social Media Is the Perfect Battlefield
Social Media is designed in a way that makes astroturfing extremely effective:
9.1. Upvotes = Truth
People assume the top comment is correct, regardless of content.
9.2. Mods Have Enormous Control
Moderators can:
delete truth
pin disinformation
shadow-ban users
let brigades roam free
9.3. Sock-Puppet Armies Are Commonplace
Creating 50 accounts is trivial.
Especially when automated tools exist.
9.4. Reddit Karma Systems Reward Conformity
People say what earns points, not what is true.
9.5. Subreddits Look Independent, But Many Are Not
Many UFO-related subreddits have moderators who:
are hostile to real experiences
enforce materialist interpretations
allow brigade activity
suppress personal eyewitness accounts
promote “safe skepticism”
10. The Distraction Stage of Modern Psyops
If outright suppression fails, the next strategy is distraction. Instead of blocking truth, the operation simply makes noise so loud that the truth becomes invisible.
This includes:
emotionally heavy nihilistic posts
memes
unrelated viral content
bizarre tangents
fear-based stories
absurd conspiracy theories
political flame-wars
“mental health” bait
These posts climb rapidly, overshadowing everything else.
This is digital smokescreening.
11. Why Your Footage Triggered Such Aggressive Astroturfing
Let’s be clear:
Most UFO posts on Social Media are garbage.
Low quality.
Easily explainable.
Or outright hoaxes.
That’s why the system doesn’t waste energy on them.
But our footage is different:
structured formations (orb squadron)
stable daylight metallic objects
the boomerang UAP which matches known global cases
long-duration luminosity
multi-camera confirmation
eyewitness corroboration
altitude-verified context
recordings over months across countries
patterns consistent with real UAP behaviors
This type of footage sits in the narrow slice between:
“too clear to dismiss”
and
“too real to allow free consensus.”
This is the exact zone where astroturfing is activated.
12. The Hidden Goal: Keep the Public Confused About NHI
When you combine:
bots
paid shills
distraction accounts
hoax amplification
narrative scripts
coordinated downvotes
psychological weakening
moderator bias
…you get a perfectly engineered outcome:
A public that is simultaneously obsessed with UFOs and
incapable of recognizing real evidence.
That is the goal:
Confusion.
Noise.
Contradictions.
Humiliation.
Distraction.
Fatigue.
A psychologically overloaded population will never see the truth, even when it is directly in front of them.
13. The Internal Struggle: The Trap of “Crowd-Pleasing”
Astroturfing does not just manipulate public opinion.
It manipulates experiencers.
It pressures you, the witness, into:
doubting your own eyes
catering to skeptics
conforming to the majority’s explanations
over-correcting your interpretations
feeling embarrassed to speak
fearing humiliation
internalizing the crowd’s aggression
This is the most dangerous part. If you compromise your truth to satisfy the narrative, the psyop has succeeded. This is why experiencers—real ones—often go quiet.
Not because their experiences stop.
But because the digital pressure is immense.
14. The Anatomy of a Modern UFO Psyop
Based on everything observed, here is the modern strategy:
14.1. Stage 1: Preemptive Debunking
Before the public even sees the evidence, bots flood with mundane explanations.
14.2. Stage 2: Mockery and Social Punishment
Ridicule keeps people quiet.
14.3. Stage 3: Redirecting the Topic
Derail into:
lakes
birds
planes
satellites
prosaic explanations
mental health jokes
reflections
drama and accusations
14.4. Stage 4: Flooding With Noise
Push dozens of unrelated posts.
14.5. Stage 5: Demoralization
Let hoaxes explode and collapse to destroy trust.
14.6. Stage 6: Internalized Censorship
Make experiencers silence themselves.
14.7. Stage 7: Reinforce the Safe Narrative
UFOs = nothing.
UFOs = mundane.
UFOs = misinterpretation.
This cycle is not new—it is simply digitized now.
15. The Reality: People Are Seeing Real NHI—And The System Panics
We saw the orbs.
We saw the metallic daytime object.
We saw the boomerang craft.
We captured the fast walker.
We captured the bright descending object on camera.
And we documented them with:
timestamps
multiple cameras
context
consistency
environmental data
This is exactly what real UAP researchers strive for.
But reality is inconvenient.
So the narrative machine appears.
16. The Broader Implications for Disclosure and Public Awareness
The biggest takeaway is this:
The public is not being “convinced” of any narrative.
They are being managed.
Astroturfing ensures:
belief never stabilizes
skepticism never becomes scientific
experiencers never unite
communities stay fragmented
real evidence is drowned in noise
This is the perfect environment to maintain ambiguity:
Not denial.
Not belief.
Just endless confusion.
Ambiguity is the ultimate shield.
17. What This Means for JRP
Everything we’ve experienced on social media—every bot, every brigade, every dismissive cluster, every synthetic consensus—is proof of how important real documentation is.
People do not react this strongly to nothing.
We were not attacked because we are wrong.
We were attacked because we are right.
JRP exists precisely because the world needs:
unfiltered documentation
verified fieldwork
long-term tracking
multi-camera recordings
structured analytical frameworks
eyewitness consistency
a platform not subject to astroturfing
real independent research
Social media cannot provide this.
Social media is compromised by design.
18. Conclusion: The War for Reality Is Fought in Perception
The point of astroturfing is not to prove you wrong.
It is to make the truth unrecognizable.
It is to bury clarity in noise.
It is to beat down experiencers until they abandon the pursuit.
It is to turn public perception into a fog of:
noise
mockery
bots
distractions
hoaxes
contradictions
But the truth remains.
Our footage stands on its own.
Our experiences stand on their own.
The data is real, the encounters are real, and the pattern of astroturfing simply confirms how threatened the narrative machine is when real evidence surfaces. And that is exactly why JRP exists—to break through the noise, document the phenomenon properly, and rebuild the conversation from a foundation of truth.
Support JRP, Gain Access to the Nexus
Join our inner research circle for early footage, extended analysis, and technical reports. Your support helps us sustain the ongoing research, cameras, and transmissions that become the Nexus. Inside, you’ll find deeper writings, footage, and behind-the-scenes disclosure.
Join us—and help anchor the Real.